Determining who is at fault in a car accident is one of the most important aspects of any claim even in Michigan’s no-fault insurance system. While your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits cover medical expenses and lost wages, fault still plays a crucial role in certain situations. If you suffered serious injuries, you may have the right to sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering. Fault also matters when damages exceed your PIP coverage, if you need to file a mini-tort claim for vehicle repairs, or when the insurance company disputes liability.

Michigan law follows comparative negligence rules, meaning your compensation can be reduced if you are found partially at fault. Understanding how liability is determined is key to protecting your right to full compensation.

Common Causes of Car Accidents & Who Is at Fault

Not every car accident is straightforward, and determining fault depends on the circumstances. Michigan law requires drivers to act responsibly and follow traffic rules, but violations like speeding, running a red light, or following too closely can determine who is legally at fault.  In most cases, the driver who fails to exercise reasonable care is considered negligent and therefore responsible for the crash. Below is a breakdown of common accident types and who is usually at fault.

🚗 Accident Type⚖️ Commonly At-Fault Party📌 Why They Are at Fault
🔴 Rear-End CollisionsRear driverFollowing too closely or not paying attention
🚦 T-Bone (Side-Impact) CrashesDriver who ran a red light or stop signFailing to yield the right-of-way
🔃 Head-On CollisionsDriver who crossed the centerlineDistracted driving, fatigue, or impairment
↩️ Left-Turn AccidentsLeft-turning driverFailing to yield to oncoming traffic
🏃‍♂️ Hit-and-Run AccidentsFleeing driverLeaving the scene of the accident is illegal
🚙💥🚗 Multi-Vehicle PileupsVariesChain-reaction crashes depend on initial cause
🚗➡️ Merging & Lane-Change AccidentsMerging driverFailing to check blind spots or signal

How Michigan’s No-Fault Insurance Affects Liability

Michigan’s no-fault insurance system means that after an accident, each driver turns to their own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage for medical expenses and lost wages regardless of who caused the crash. However, fault still matters in certain situations.  If your injuries are severe enough or your losses exceed PIP limits, you may be able to hold the at-fault driver responsible for additional damages. Here’s how fault impacts different aspects of a car accident claim in Michigan:

  • Medical Bills & Lost Wages: Covered by your own No-Fault PIP insurance, no matter who caused the accident.
  • Pain & Suffering Lawsuits: Only possible if your injuries meet Michigan’s serious impairment threshold.
  • Vehicle Damage (Mini-Tort Claims): You may recover up to $3,000 from the at-fault driver if they were at least 50% responsible for the crash.
  • Exceeding PIP Coverage: If your medical costs go beyond your PIP policy limits, you may sue the at-fault driver for excess damages.

Michigan’s no-fault laws aim to reduce lawsuits, but serious injury cases and disputes over liability still happen. In these situations, fault must be established before additional compensation can be pursued.

Michigan’s Comparative Negligence Law – How Fault Affects Compensation

Michigan follows a modified comparative negligence rule (MCL 600.2959), which means that your ability to recover compensation depends on your percentage of fault. If you’re found partially responsible for a crash, your settlement will be reduced by that percentage.

For example, if you are 30% at fault for an accident and your damages total $100,000, your compensation would be reduced by 30%, leaving you with $70,000. However, if you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover pain and suffering damages but may still receive economic benefits like medical expenses through your PIP coverage.

⚖️ Fault Percentage💰 Can You Recover Compensation?📌 What Happens?
0% (Not at Fault)✅ Full compensationYou can recover all eligible damages
1-50% at Fault✅ Partial compensationAward reduced by your % of fault
51% or More❌ No pain & suffering damagesYou can only recover No-Fault benefits

Proving Fault in a Michigan Car Accident Case

Establishing fault in a car accident is crucial, especially if you need to recover compensation beyond No-Fault benefits. Insurance companies often dispute liability to minimize payouts, so gathering strong evidence is essential.  Key evidence used to prove fault includes:

  • Police Reports – Official accident reports often indicate which driver violated traffic laws.
  • Witness Statements – Testimonies from bystanders can support your claim.
  • Traffic Camera & Dashcam Footage – Video evidence can clearly show how the accident happened.
  • Vehicle Damage Analysis – The location and severity of damage can indicate which driver was responsible.
  • Accident Reconstruction Experts – Specialists may be needed in complex cases to determine how the crash occurred.

When You Can Sue the At-Fault Driver in Michigan

Michigan’s no-fault system limits lawsuits in most car accident cases, but there are exceptions where you can take legal action against the at-fault driver. If your injuries are severe or your damages exceed PIP coverage, you may have the right to sue for additional compensation.  Not every accident qualifies for a lawsuit. Below is a breakdown of when you can and cannot file a claim against the at-fault driver in Michigan.

⚖️ Situation💰 Can You Sue for Compensation?📌 What You Can Recover
Serious Injury (Impairment of Bodily Function)✅ YesPain & suffering, excess medical costs, lost wages
Permanent Disfigurement✅ YesCompensation for visible, lasting injuries
Wrongful Death✅ YesFuneral costs, loss of income, emotional damages
Medical Costs Exceed PIP Limits✅ YesAny costs beyond no-fault coverage
Minor Injuries Covered by PIP❌ NoYou must rely on your PIP benefits

What If You’re Being Blamed for a Car Accident?

If the other driver or their insurance company is trying to place blame on you, it can significantly impact your ability to recover compensation. Michigan’s comparative negligence law means that if you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover pain and suffering damages. Even if you are partially at fault (50% or less), your compensation will be reduced by your percentage of blame.  To protect your rights and dispute unfair blame, take the following steps:

  • Request the Police Report – This report may contain key details about who was at fault.
  • Gather Evidence – Photos, videos, and witness statements can help prove what really happened.
  • Avoid Admitting Fault – Even saying “I’m sorry” can be used against you. Stick to the facts.
  • Consult an Attorney – A lawyer can challenge an unfair fault assessment and negotiate with the insurance company.

FAQs About Fault in Michigan Car Accidents

Who determines fault in a Michigan car accident?

Fault is determined by police officers, insurance companies, and sometimes the courts. Police reports, witness statements, traffic laws, and physical evidence all play a role in assessing liability.

Can both drivers be at fault for an accident in Michigan?

Yes. Michigan follows a comparative negligence rule, meaning both drivers can share fault. If you are 50% or less at fault, you can still recover damages, but your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover pain and suffering damages.

Can I sue another driver if Michigan is a no-fault state?

Yes, but only under certain conditions. You can file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver if you suffered a serious impairment of a bodily function, permanent disfigurement, or if the accident resulted in a wrongful death. You may also sue if your medical expenses exceed your no-fault PIP insurance limits.

How do I prove the other driver was at fault?

Proving fault requires strong evidence, including the official police report, witness statements, and any available traffic camera or dashcam footage. In more complex cases, accident reconstruction experts may be needed to analyze the crash. Gathering this evidence quickly is critical to building a strong claim.

What if the at-fault driver doesn’t have insurance?

If the other driver is uninsured, you may still have options for compensation. Uninsured motorist coverage through your own policy can provide financial recovery. If you do not have this coverage, you may be able to file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver’s personal assets. In certain cases, Michigan’s Assigned Claims Plan (MACP) may offer limited benefits.

What should I do if the insurance company says I’m at fault?

If the insurance company unfairly assigns you fault, do not accept blame or agree to a settlement without consulting an attorney. You have the right to challenge their findings. Collecting additional evidence, such as video footage or expert witness testimony, can help dispute an incorrect liability determination. A lawyer can negotiate on your behalf to ensure you receive fair compensation.

Do I need a lawyer to prove fault in a Michigan car accident?

You are not required to have a lawyer, but working with an attorney can significantly improve your chances of proving fault and maximizing your compensation. Insurance companies often try to shift blame or offer low settlements. A skilled lawyer will gather evidence, deal with insurance adjusters, and fight back against unfair liability claims to protect your rights.

Speak With a Michigan Car Accident Lawyer About Your Case

If you were injured in a car accident in Michigan and are unsure who is at fault, The Clark Law Office can help. Our experienced attorneys can investigate your crash, challenge unfair fault determinations, and fight to maximize your compensation.  We handle all car accident cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we win. Call us today to discuss your case and protect your rights. See how fault is determined and how it connects to the full legal process in our car accident law and process guide.

5/5 - (1 vote)